Islam: Sunni and Shia

I was recently asked what the difference was between Sunni and Shia Muslims, a subject which I had looked up a few years ago, at a time of earlier troubles in the Middle East.

It was all down to the question of who should succeed Mohammed the Prophet, who died in 632. Should it be his closest blood relation, or based on whoever was best qualified to perform the many roles of the Prophet? The chosen person would be called the “Caliph”, which means “successor” and can also mean “Allah’s deputy on Earth”. The Prophet had made it clear that he was the last prophet in the Abrahamic tradition, so that his successor would not be a prophet. What was needed was a devout religious and political leader as well as a military commander and a judge, all roles which Mohammed had performed.

The Prophet’s only surviving child was his daughter Fatima, who was married to his cousin, Ali. They were the parents of Hasan and Hussein, the Prophet’s grandsons. There was support for Ali to be successor, based on his relationship to the Prophet. The supporters of Ali later acquired the name the “Shia” meaning the “partisans”. The Elders at Mecca decided to make Abu Bekr Caliph. He was an early convert to Islam and had fought with Mohammed in his campaigns. He was of the same tribe as the Prophet and the father of the Prophet’s widow, Aisha. He was chosen basis on his ability, character and experience.

Islam is understood and interpreted by study of the Qur’an itself and of “the Sunna”, which are the records of the ways and sayings of the Prophet. Those who did not want succession to be by the blood line but rather by those best able to understand the Qur’an and the Sunna later became known as “the Sunni”.

Ali eventually became Caliph but only after the murder of the third Caliph, Uthman of the Umayyad tribe, in 656 by some fanatical supporters of Ali. This led to a revolt by the Umayyads against Ali. Some of his more extreme supporters, being seriously dissatisfied with Ali for not supressing the revolt, murdered him in 661.

This led to the takeover by the Umayyad Caliphate, which continued in power in the Middle East until 749, when the Abbasids took over and founded Baghdad. The Umayyads continued longer in Spain.

Most Muslim countries are now wholly or predominantly Sunni, the main exception being Iran, which is Shia. To some extent this explains the assistance from Iran to Shiites in the region, such as in Iraq, Lebanon, Yemen, and Syria.

I have no theological qualifications, but my understanding is that there are no great differences in the religious beliefs of the Sunni and Shia. Their differences are based on the issue of who should succeed the Prophet.

Post Views : 3